lukajk / blog / skill, ability, talent

apr 08 25 01:42am
last modified apr 25 25 07:49pm

Ofc these terms don't have any strict definitions in general use and are somewhat interchangeable but I have to put a name to concepts for my own thoughts skill - capacity for an isolated task that is virtually entirely correlative with time investment because of its physically founded nature in growing myelin insulation. Everyone is equally capable of growing it (other things equal). ex: the feeling of forming a backflip, or kickflip, or probably any sportsball maneuver (although this is not quite accurate because these aren't fully "linearly correlative with time investment," that requirement always will inherently be influenced by talent, in reality. But that difference comes from how often myelin sheaths are being strengthened rather than the sheaths themselves growing faster in one person than another.) I think knowledge might play a bit of an interesting role - researchers love to study chess players and an idea that comes up quite a lot is that they have developed an extensive library of games that forms the basis for their ability to read the board in chunks like "lines of force," and so on. I imagine the games themselves are partially synonymous with heavily insulated myelin--recalling a game calls on these chunked patterns where each move influences what comes next, perhaps in the same way that we recall the chronological ordering of events in a book. Then the two are quite woven together. So perhaps knowledge is nearly quite directly skill. At the least all experience and information pertaining to a discipline would be categorized under this umbrella. -> knowledge > reasoning This is somewhat distinct from crystallized intelligence (Gc) since that correlates with fluid (Gf) and general intelligence, but similar in the sense that most of the trait derives from the base of "experiences". talent - this one is untouched from the generally understood definition of talent: whatever initial capacity you have for a discipline at the start (before you've practiced at all). This is the combination of intelligence in the statistical trait sense (g / Gf), and positively contributing life experiences (good mental demonstrated by a parental figure, etc). Raw intelligence is far from the full picture of talent itself, let alone ability as a whole. Your experiences affect how you respond to failure, approach various types of problems (for one reason or another you may have seen one in a similar form before), where you derive your sense of drive, and inform your attitude and understanding of the discipline, to name a few. ability - the overall demonstrated proficiency in a discipline. More or less the idea of "skill" in its typical usage. This is the combination of skill and talent. ex: the ability to paint realistically, or read sheet music, etc